Country western singer Johnny Lee recorded the song “Lookin’ For Love.” The lyrics go “Lookin’ for love in all the wrong places, lookin’ for love in too many faces.” The same is true for many of us as we go “lookin’ for esteem in all the wrong places.”
To esteem something is to set a high value on it, to regard it highly, and to prize it accordingly. So self-esteem is to set a high value on ourselves, to regard ourselves highly, and to prize ourselves. We see this focus on “self” all around us; the self-awareness books and seminars, and the self-improvement industry all teach us to get in touch with our “inner selves” to find happiness, confidence, and self-esteem.
The self-esteem crusade is rampant with its insidious tentacles reaching into the classrooms of our own children. In my daughter’s first grade class the school offered an hour long self-esteem class three times a week. Parents were told attendance was not mandatory, but no alternative was given for parents who didn’t want their 5-year old children to get “self-esteem” training. In a school of nearly 500 children, my daughter was the only one not in attendance. She spent this hour in the library reading her favorite books.
Why not let her attend you may ask? First, because on close examination the course material was thinly disguised Eastern religion complete with relaxation exercises, visualization, centering, developing spirit guides, etc. Of course, the material didn’t use those exact words but the techniques they were professing were unmistakably similar. Second, self-esteem is the wrong focus for our children, and for us.
The “me” generation of the 60’s spawned most of the self-esteem culture. There was “free love,” marijuana, incense, transactional analysis, and a host of cultural changes that encouraged people to focus on themselves; their needs and their wants. Perhaps the closest Biblical parallel would be life in Sodom or Gomorrah.
Our business culture is not immune to the “self-esteem” advocates. There are dozens of seminars and consultants who in the name of increasing employee morale, sensitivity, or improved productivity teach us to get in touch with our “inner selves.” They tell us that if “I’m OK, You’re OK.” They say that we can’t value others until we value ourselves. The key to self-esteem they say is to focus on liking yourself. The humanist psychologists made popular the concepts of personal identity, positive self-image, self-actualization, self-esteem, and self-worth.
What psychobabble! We would all be a lot better off if we valued ourselves less, and God more. Can you imagine Jesus saying that he was greater than the Father? Can you imagine Jesus trying to find value in others by liking himself more? Or can you imagine Jesus becoming “self-actualized” by visualizing himself dying on the cross? If you have a hard time bringing these pictures up in your mind then you know that “self-esteem” as proffered by the world is not the Biblical solution.
The one thing that humanistic psychology and Biblical Christianity agree on is that we need to get to know ourselves. Humanist psychologists say we need to get to know ourselves so that we can feel good about ourselves. Whereas Biblical Christianity teaches us to know ourselves so that we might turn away from ourselves, and towards Jesus Christ.
Psychology versus Christianity
Where humanist psychology and Christianity disagree is how to develop a strong sense of belonging, worthiness, and competence.
Psychologists Adler and Maslow created hierarchies of need. Adler created a model of three steps (security needs, significance needs, and satisfaction through power) while Maslow’s model had five (physiological needs, safety and security needs, love and belongingness needs, self-esteem needs, and self-actualization needs).
Both Adler and Maslow believed that man needed to move up the hierarchy in order. For example, you couldn’t feel or give love until you had all your needs for security met. They believed that man could not love others until he first learned to love himself.
The Bible provides a completely different view. For example, rather than saying we need to love ourselves before we can love others, the Bible says we should loathe ourselves; “Then you will remember your evil ways and wicked deeds, and you will loathe yourselves for your sins and detestable practices” (Ezekial 36:31).
Jesus instructed the apostles to love their enemies, “But I tell you who hear me: Love your enemies, do good to those who hate you, bless those who curse you, pray for those who mistreat you” (Luke 6:27-28). Not only are we to love our enemies, but we are to do good to them, bless them, and imagine this, pray for them! Nowhere in this teaching does Jesus make an exception for us in loving others only when we have learned to “love ourselves” first.
Jesus goes on to reinforce the need to love our enemies, “If you love those who love you, what credit is that to you? Even ‘sinners’ love those who love them. And if you do good to those who are good to you, what credit is that to you? Even ‘sinners’ do that” (Luke 6:32-33). Again, there is no teaching that says we need to love ourselves before we can love others. In fact, we are directed to love our enemies regardless of whether we have learned to love ourselves.
Biblical Christianity and humanistic psychology also hold opposite views when it comes to self-image.
Psychologists tell us we need to have a high self-image. Not a realistic self-image mind you, but a high self-image. They say we need this inflated self-image to counter the effects of our negative surroundings.
We cannot find these teachings in the Bible. In fact, God’s word cautions us to have accurate, not inflated self-images. Paul wrote to the Galatians, “If anyone thinks he is something when he is nothing, he deceives himself” (Gal. 6:3).
Paul warned the Romans not to think too much of themselves; “Do not think of yourselves more highly than you ought, but rather think of yourself in sober judgment, in accordance with the measure of faith that God has given you” (Romans 12:3).
Whatever skills and strengths we have they were given to us by God, and we should be careful not to think of ourselves as better than others. Rather, we should consider ourselves soberly in light of the faith that God has given us.
We have discussed the world’s view of the importance of self, and hopefully, you see how the worldview does not match the Biblical view. If we discard the world’s notion that we need to worry about our self-esteem, and that we cannot love others until we first love ourselves, how then are we to live? What is God’s plan for our emotional health?
Over and over in the Bible God says we need to deny ourselves and focus on Him. How do we stay focused on God? One way is to learn how to lead humble lives.
The idea of being humble is pretty foreign to most of us in the business world. We have been raised with slogans like “you’ve got to toot your own horn,” and “you first, after me.”
To be humble means to be low-minded, not proud, haughty, or arrogant. God wants us to be humble, not proud, “God opposes the proud but gives grace to the humble” (James 4:6). If we want God’s help rather than His opposition then we need to lead a humble life.
James goes on to describe the proper attitude, “Submit yourselves, then, to God. Resist the devil, and he will flee from you. Come near to God and he will come near to you. Wash your hands, you sinners, and purify your hearts, you double-minded. Grieve, mourn and wail. Change your laughter to mourning and your joy to gloom” (James 4:7-9).
Here are seven steps taken directly from this passage that will help us get our focus on God, and off of ourselves.
1) Submit yourselves
The first step is to submit ourselves to God. Matthew 6:10 says His will be done, not my will. You cannot come before God as a humble servant until you are willing to submit yourself to His will.
2) Resist the devil
The expression, “The devil made me do it” doesn’t cut it. God says He gives us the power to do all things through Him, and that includes resisting Satan. When Satan tempted Jesus, Jesus answered him with scripture and Satan left (Matthew 4:1-11). When we are tempted to do a shady deal or act in some other way that we know is not honoring to God we must stand firm and resist the temptation.
3) Come near to God
Think of your closest friend. Hours and hours are invested in making that relationship a rich and rewarding one. A relationship with God is much the same; we must spend time developing the relationship. We must come to God through reading and studying His Word, through hearing the Word (church and Bible studies), and through prayer. When we come to God He promises to come to us.
4) Wash your hands
Temple priests were required to wash their hands before entering the tent of meeting or giving a sacrifice. The washing of hands was an outward sign of an inward spiritual cleansing. James’ admonishment is that our outward actions must be pure. Whether at work, in the community, or in our homes, we must live lives of integrity honoring to God.
5) Purify your hearts
Have you ever known someone who said nice things to your face but stabbed you in the back when it benefitted them? James is warning us that we cannot be double minded; we cannot serve both God and manna. The attitude of our heart is just as important as our actions. Some people serve at church and put on a happy face that says they enjoy helping the poor or less fortunate. In reality, they are serving out of a sense of obligation. Have you ever encouraged someone at work to do something you knew was not in their best interests? Rest assured God knows the attitude of our hearts.
6) Grieve, mourn, and wail
Sin separates us from God, but a repentant heart restores us. When we fail we should admit our mistakes immediately to God. We should also realize that the sins of others keep them from a close relationship with God, and this is indeed something to weep over.
7) Serious commitment
James was not prescribing a dejected, humorless life when he said, “change your laughter to mourning and your joy to gloom.” Rather, he wants us to understand the seriousness of a life-long commitment to a relationship with God. Many people in James’ day thought happiness and success were signs of a close relationship with God. But remember what happened to Job? Job was wealthy, powerful, and had a large family. When he lost his family, his wealth, and his power his friends turned on him. Job’s own wife suggested that he curse God and die. But through it all, Job remained focused on God. Job even prayed for the very friends that had turned on him. God subsequently restored Job’s fortune and his family.
One Final Thought
Jesus, instructing the disciples said, “Whoever exalts himself will be humbled, and whoever humbles himself will be exalted” (Mat. 23:12). It’s pretty clear; if we want to be exalted by man we should lead prideful, arrogant lives. If we want to be exalted by God we should lead humble lives.
Don’t look in the mirror for esteem, you’re far too fallible. Don’t look to family and friends for esteem, they are just as fallible. Rather, be like Job who through the best of times and the worst of times, looked up to God preferring to have God’s esteem rather than man’s.
In his book, The Winning Attitude, author John Maxwell notes a formula for spiritual success, “If you want to be distressed, look within. If you want to be defeated, look back. If you want to be distracted, look around. If you want to be dismayed, look ahead. If you want to be delivered, look up!”
Lookin’ For Esteem in All the Wrong Places is also available in the form of a bonus whitepaper. This 11-page bonus whitepaper includes more about the struggle between self-esteem and God-esteem, some great quotes, a real-life case study, a template you can use to complete a personal review, and nine key points to maintaining a balanced life. You can download it here:
Join the Conversation
As always questions and comments are welcome! Have you or someone you know, struggled with self-esteem issues, but lacked God esteem? How did it affect your/their lives?
I’d love your help. This blog is read primarily because people like you share it with friends. Would you share it by pressing one of the share buttons below?
Next Week: “Are You Peter on Monday Morning?” A look at the tendency to hide our Christianity in the workplace.
Category: Personal Development | Dependence on God